January 4th, 2019
Self-evaluation
The recent order on education forces us to evaluate our students by their competences. At a theoretical level, this change is very positive and favorable for the students’ development. Now, at a pragmatic level, it’s hard to know how to apply it correctly. One of the strategies that we apply is self-evaluation. That is, we as teachers evaluate them according to a criteria, and the student, who knows from the beginning of the project about the items that will be evaluated, can evaluate themselves at the end of the project. This way, we can see what the students’ perception of the work that they do and the work that’s required from them is, and if necessary, we can help them get better.
The rubric is a very important item to evaluate where they think they are. It helps us know what they have accomplished, and the things that still need to be accomplished. Therefore, as a self-evaluation element, it is fundamental to be aware and have knowledge of what they do and is expected from them. From there, they decide if they want to get there or not, and in case they don’t know how to do it, they can ask for help to whoever, however, and whenever!
I think that self-evaluation is useful for students, so that they can determine where they are and are able to decide if they want to stay there or not. Sometimes, a student can feel unsatisfied with his/her results, but he/she doesn’t know how to change that
or simply doesn’t want to change anything. These are the decisions that they have to make, and we as teachers, try to give them the elements so we can guide those decisions, without deciding for them.
If a student gets a higher self-evaluation than the one made by his/her classmates or teacher, we have to talk to him/her. We have to find out what we did so that the results weren’t as positive as the student believes. The same happens the other way around. Now, once we are aware of this, changing this is up to the student. We made it obvious, we have compared the evaluations and offered or proposed things that can help them improve, but they decide whether to do it or not. I think that this point is very important.
We deal with giving the tools to decide, but we don’t decide for them.